The chief financial officer of futures broker MF Global told Standard & Poor’s that the firm’s finances had “never been stronger” just a week before it filed for bankruptcy.
In a letter to the US House Financial Services subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations, S&P; said that CFO Henri Steenkamp had sent the rating agency an email on 24 October saying that “MF Global’s capital and liquidity has never been stronger”, Bloomberg reports. The firm filed for chapter 11 bankruptcy on 31 October.
“MF Global is in its strongest position ever as [a] public entity,” the letter added.
Additionally, S&P; said that former MF Global chief executive Jon Corzine reassured its analysts that a $6.3bn (€4.8bn) bet on European sovereign debt posed no threat to the firm’s finances.
Congressman Randy Neugebauer, who chairs the House subcommittee, is presiding over a hearing on Thursday to study the watchfulness of the rating agencies before MF Global filed for bankruptcy.
S&P; had warned that it could downgrade MF Global’s BBB- rating on 26 October, a day after the firm posted its quarterly results.
Moody’s had downgraded the broker to a Baa3 rating – one above junk status – on 24 October, partly due to its large exposure to European sovereign debt. By 27 October it lowered the firm’s rating another two notches to Ba2.
A memorandum before the meeting, sent to committee members on Friday, questioned why the rating agencies had left it so long to downgrade the firm when it had posted details about its large EU sovereign debt exposures as early as May 2011.
“By way of contrast, the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority immediately identified MF Global’s exposure to European sovereign debt as a concern during a routine review of MF Global’s audited financial statements that were filed with Finra on May 31, 2011,” the document says.
However, the firm’s collapse “cannot be said” to have resulted from the rating downgrades, it added.
No comments yet.
Login
Register
Most read
Most commented
GFS is pleased to offer you a two-week free trial.
You will receive a daily email bulletin of the latest regulatory news and analysis and a weekly email round-up.
Please complete the free trial form.
You will also receive full access to our online site.