Global Financial Strategy

Search the site   >>Advanced search
First for financial regulatory news and views
HOME   |   REGISTER   |   SUBSCRIBE   |   NEWS   |   ANALYSIS   |   INTERVIEWS & FEATURES   |   EVENTS   |   MUTTERS   |   JOBS   |   MY ACCOUNT
EUROPE   |    US & CANADA   |    ASIA PACIFIC   |    MIDDLE EAST & AFRICA   |    LATIN AMERICA & CARIBBEAN   |    OFFSHORE   |    SINGAPORE   |    HONG KONG
TRADING   |    CASINO MARKET   |    BANKING   |    INSURANCE   |    FINANCIAL REPORTING   |    TAXATION   |    MACROECONOMIC   |    PROFILES   |   CONTACT   |   
  • MF Global spoke of 'strong' finances
  • EC: No corp gov powers for ESAs
  • FSA appoints senior investment bank adviser
  • GFS has now closed
  • Czechs join UK on fiscal compact sidelines
  • Davos stalemate on EU's IMF funds
  • Tucker: Resolution regime 'top priority'
  • Saudi Arabia increases central bank role
  • FSB urges Canada for one securities regulator
  • CFTC set for committee to scrutinise HFT
  • Fitch downgrades Belgian banks
  • What corruption really costs
  • UK FSA pushes for Mifid II rethink on OTCs
  • Shanghai boosts global financial status
  • Canada aligns credit rating rules with EU
  • Bowles blasts lack of women at ECB
  • Sarkozy to introduce French FTT in August
  • Barnier warns on further bonus reforms
GFS LinkedIn
GFS Facebook
GFS Twitter
GFS RSS feed
You must be logged in to use this function.


CRA rotation may reduce competition

Tuesday 24 January 2012 – by Karina Whalley


The proposed mandatory rotation of credit rating agencies used by companies could actually reduce competition among agencies, industry experts and MEPs said during an Econ meeting.

The European Parliament’s Economic and Monetary Affairs committee held a public hearing on Monday and Tuesday where experts argued that stepping up the supervision of credit rating agencies could help to eliminate their conflicts of interest.

French MEP, Jean-Paul Gauzes said the European Commission proposal to oblige companies to rotate CRA’s was of “no interest” since “it is not going to increase competition”.

Susan Launi, the senior counsel at Fitch Ratings which is the smallest of the three main credit rating agencies was worried the rotation provision will have the “unintended negative consequence” of reinforcing the duopoly held by Moody’s and Standard & Poor’s.

“To meet the demands of the proposed rotation, issuers will most probably use two CRAs at a time”, Launi added, which will contradict the proposal’s aim to have more opinions in the market.

Verena Ross, the executive director of the European Securities and Markets Authority also said the rotation clause could harm the quality of ratings – at least in the short term.

Related articles:
EC retaliation on rating agencies overrated
EC scraps ‘costly’ EU credit rating agency
Barnier hits out at S&P; downgrades
Esma rejects two CRA registrations
Esma advises against non-EU CRAs
S&P;: Why we changed our rating criteria

But Ross said that several proposed provisions “would have a positive effect on CRA supervision”, including rules on disclosure, conflicts of interest, a harmonised rating scale and civil liability for infringements in the third series of regulation since 2009.

Esma was urged to conduct “a broader investigation of CRA’s conflict of interest”, by German MEP Sven Giegold who proposed setting up public foundations.

The Socialist Group’s rapporteur, MEP Leonardo Domenici, called on the European Parliament to think about setting up a European regulatory agency for CRAs. He lambasted the current rating agency rules for having failed and urged for them to be reformed.

Finance Watch secretary general Thierry Philipponnat said “no single opinion should ever be allowed to influence the entire system” as all opinions are “subject to the possibility of error”.

He said the use of letters, number and symbols should be forbidden, especially for unsolicited ratings over sovereign debt and only textual arguments should be allowed by agencies.



WHAT DO YOU THINK?
 
Name:
   
Email:
   
Comment:
   
Post as Anonymous
  Display name
   
Please, enter security code
   
 

No comments yet.
Login Register Most read Most commented
Username

Password

>> Forgotten your password?
>> Sign Up  

GFS is pleased to offer you a two-week free trial. You will receive a daily email bulletin of the latest regulatory news and analysis and a weekly email round-up. Please complete the free trial form. You will also receive full access to our online site.

EDITOR’S CHOICE

  • Diamond warns against ‘Balkanisation’
  • ABI: UK insurers must keep EU links
  • EU Parliament site hit by hacktivists
  • George Soros: New year, same crisis
  • FSB: Swiss regulator needs more teeth
  • OCC: Deriv fears are an overreaction
  • ‘Major wave’ of Solvency II drafts in May
  • IMF paper urges Aus bank capital boost
  • BoE: Limit bonuses to boost bank capital
  • 2012 vision: Increased regulatory exposure looms
  • Barnier offers hope to NYSE/Boerse
  • Esma rushes short selling consultation
  • Bowles re-elected as Econ chair
  • Hoogervorst hints at accounting slowdown
  • Asia in the year of the dragon
  • Barnier: FTT will not be forced on UK
INTERVIEWS & FEATURES

STRAW POLL

Will markets in 2012 have a tougher time than 2011?

Yes

No

Don’t know

View results

FIND A REGION
 
Global Financial Strategy - [email protected] | Home | Legal | Contact design by SDV